Therapy is probably helping if the thing you came for has started to shift, you and your therapist could both say what you're working on, and you can raise hard things in session. You can check all three with a pen in about ten minutes. Below are six questions, a sentence for each pattern of answers, and what research and Ontario's rules add.

Six questions to answer on paper

Pick a quiet moment a day or two away from a session, because the hour right after one can colour everything. Keep the page to compare with in a month or two.

  1. What did I first come to therapy for? Use the words you'd have used back then.
  2. From 0 to 10, how much did it get in the way of my life when I started, and how much this past week?
  3. What have I done in the past month that I couldn't have done, or wouldn't have tried, when I began?
  4. Could I say in one sentence what my therapist and I are working towards? Would they say the same?
  5. Do I feel understood and respected in sessions, including when the work is uncomfortable?
  6. What have I been holding back from saying there, and what stops me?

The number in question 2 is rough, and that's fine. It works like the scaling question used in solution-focused sessions: you're looking for direction, and a move of one point can be worth talking about. Next to it, jot down anything big that happened outside therapy. The same 7 means something different in a month when you lost your job than in a quiet month.

A filled-in page, invented to show the format

QuestionInvented answer
What I came forWaking at 3 a.m. and going over everything I might have got wrong
0 to 10, then and now8 then, 6 this week
Something new this monthTold a colleague I needed another day on a report, and slept that night
What we're working towardsNot sure. We talk about work a lot, but I couldn't put the aim in a sentence
Understood and respectedYes, mostly
Holding backThe writing exercises between sessions don't suit me, and I keep saying they're fine

This page shows movement, plus two things worth raising: the unclear aim and the exercises. Neither one is a reason to leave.

What your answers may point to

Treat these as starting points. Your therapist may read the situation differently, and hearing how is part of what you're asking for.

What you see on the pageWhat it may point toA sentence you could use
You feel understood, but the number hasn't movedThe aim or the method may need another look"I feel heard here, and my sleep is about where it was in spring. Can we look at what we're doing?"
You couldn't name a shared aimThe goal was never set, or it has drifted"If this were going well, what would be different in three months? I'd like us to agree on that."
Something is changing, but you dread goingSomething between you may need saying"Last week, when you moved on quickly from my mother, I felt brushed off."
An exercise or technique doesn't suit youOnly that tool may be the problem"I haven't been doing the writing. Is there another way to get at the same thing?"
Sessions shake you for a couple of days, and life is slowly easierThe pace may need adjusting"Could we slow down on this, or leave the last ten minutes for settling?"
You've raised it, and nothing has changedIt may be time to discuss other options"I've said this twice and we're still in the same place. Should we talk about whether to continue?"

Two kinds of feeling worse

A hard hour that settles within a day or two is one thing. A low that keeps building week after week is another, and it's worth raising at your next session, with your family doctor too if you have one.

A 2016 survey in the British Journal of Psychiatry asked people treated at 184 services in England and Wales whether they'd had lasting bad effects from psychological treatment. Of 14,587 who answered, 5.2% said yes. People who felt they'd been given enough information before starting were less likely to say so, and those unsure which type of therapy they were having were more likely to. The survey can't show that one caused the other, but it makes two questions reasonable at any point: "What is this approach called?" and "What can I expect from it?"

If the low comes with thoughts of not wanting to be alive, please tell someone today, including your therapist. In an emergency, call 9-8-8 (Suicide Crisis Helpline, 24/7), call 911 or go to the nearest emergency department.

How long before you can tell

There's no single number. A systematic review in Psychotherapy Research looked at 26 studies of therapy in routine settings. Improvement tended to come faster early on and slow later, and the authors estimated that the point of best return fell between 4 and 26 sessions, depending on the setting, the problem and how it was measured. They found little evidence either way for severe or long-standing difficulties, so the range doesn't tell anyone in that position when to expect change.

A practical way round the uncertainty is to ask early: "When should we stop and look at how this is going?"

Why these questions

  • Questions 4 and 5 are about what researchers call the alliance: agreeing on goals and tasks, and the bond between you and your therapist. A 2018 meta-analysis of 295 studies and more than 30,000 people found a consistent link between the alliance and how therapy turned out (r = .278 in person, about the same for therapy online). A link like this can't show which comes first, since people who are improving may also come to feel better about their therapist.
  • Question 2 is a home-made version of routine outcome monitoring, where someone fills in a short questionnaire regularly and the results feed back into therapy. A 2023 review of 11 meta-analyses put the average advantage at about 8% over standard care, with more for people who weren't on track when extra tools were used. The authors add that it doesn't work for everyone. You can ask any therapist whether they use a questionnaire like this, or whether you could try one together.

What Ontario's rules say about this conversation

You aren't overstepping by asking. For Registered Psychotherapists, the College of Registered Psychotherapists of Ontario writes it into Standard 3.5:

"Registrants involve clients in determining whether therapy offers a reasonable prospect of benefit."

The same standard says registrants discuss the option of stopping when therapy appears to have ceased to be effective, and it gives periodically reassessing goals with the client as an example of meeting it. Other professions, such as social workers and psychologists, have their own colleges and rules.

If you decide to change or stop

You'd be far from alone. A 2012 meta-analysis of 669 studies found that about one person in five dropped out of therapy. A closing conversation can still be useful, and a short message is enough if that feels like too much.

  1. Say it plainly: "I've decided to finish after next week, and I'd like to use that session to go over what's changed."
  2. Ask for your therapist's view of what helped, in words you can carry forward.
  3. Ask whether they can suggest another person or another approach.
  4. Write down what suited you and what didn't while it's fresh, along with your six answers.
  5. Bring that page to the next person. The article on starting psychotherapy in Ontario covers how to look for someone.

Talking about this with BridgeMinds

Carolina Vintu, PhD, Registered Psychotherapist, works online with adults and adolescents across Ontario, in English, Russian and Romanian. The page on individual therapy describes how sessions are set up. In a free 15-minute consultation, you can say what has and hasn't suited you so far, and ask how she approaches goals and reviewing progress.